No, the New Jersey Devils Don't Always Make Backup Goalies Look Great

Al Montoya, the first backup, or non-regular starter, the Devils have faced in the 2013-14 season. - Bruce Fedyck-USA TODAY Sports

Al Montoya, expected to be Winnipeg's backup got his first start against the New Jersey Devils on Sunday night and shut them out. In light of that, I look the past to see whether the Devils always make backup (non-regular) goalies look good.

Last night, the New Jersey Devils got to face who will likely be the #2 goaltender for Winnipeg this season: Al Montoya. And he shut them out in a 3-0 loss. A common lament I've heard at games in advance of last night's game comes to mind. The notion that the Devils make backups look superior like they are Vezina winners, Dominik Hasek, a wall, and so forth. I can sympathize with the frustration. Especially after last night's game. I'd argue that's more on the Devils not forcing Montoya enough to be great as opposed to Montoya being great, but a 100% save percentage is still a 100% save percentage. The sight that the goaltender who does not regularly start for the opposition stopping everything in sight is a hard one to take. It's hard to forget, which I think fuels that notion that some degree. But let's consider it further anyway.

When I say backup, it's more accurate to call them non-regular starters. There are a myriad of reasons why the Devils would see these sorts of goalies. The notion of the backup itself has changed in recent seasons. Several teams now operate with a #1 and #1A option, splitting time more evenly. Injuries have caused some goalies to play more than they otherwise would. Poor performance could force a coach to start someone else just to "send a message" or "hope for a different result." The schedule could dictate who they see, be it a team just splitting goalies on a back-to-back set or playing someone based on whether the Devils are the stronger or weaker matchup. Whatever the reason, the Devils - like most teams - will see someone in net that may not get the majority of starts in net for the season.

I decided to go back four seasons of game-by-game data from I noted who the starting goalie was and determined their save percentage for each game. I cross-referenced the opposition goalies and noted whether they were the #1 for their team in that season based on how many starts the goalie has received. In each season, the #1 goalie designation would certainly be arguable for a few teams due to injury, usage, and performance. I did the best that I could. I did not sort out data based on back-ups coming into games in relief so this isn't a complete analysis. However, it's enough to put this notion to bed.

2009-10 vs. Not #1s 29 68 68 882 761 0.923
2009-10 vs. #1s 53 148 118 1577 1452 0.906
2010-11 vs. Not #1s 32 78 77 907 846 0.914
2010-11 vs. #1s 50 93 130 1437 1306 0.935
2011-12 vs. Not #1s 30 91 56 831 777 0.890
2011-12 vs. #1s 52 125 149 1422 1422 0.912
2013 vs. Not #1s 10 31 26 286 211 0.892
2013 vs. #1s 38 79 96 1076 899 0.927

The last time the #1 goalies did worse than their #1 goalies against the Devils was back in the 2009-10 season. Keep in mind that the Not #1s from that season included goalies were or would eventually be #1s later in the list like Tuukka Rask, Mike Smith, Jean-Sebastien Gigurere, Ondrej Pavelec, and Antti Niemi. Still, from that season onward, the Devils found more success against the non-regular starters. Even in the 2010-11 season when all opposition goaltenders collectively put up a 92.7% save percentage against New Jersey.

Yes, the Devils have had their nights where the #2 (or #3) has stunned the Devils with saves everywhere. From last season, one can recall Jonas Enroth doing it all until the last shot he faced (he hurt himself on the play) and Ben Bishop stopping 32 of 34 in a territorially-lopsided game. TBut as those stand out, one forgets that the 2013 Devils put plenty past Dan Ellis (played as much as Cam Ward but wouldn't have if Ward didn't get hurt) and handed sub-90% nights to Anders Lindback, Tomas Vokoun, Mathieu Garon, and Anton Khudobin too. Then again, they went 2-1-1 in those four so perhaps they weren't so memorable. Two seasons ago, Al Montoya did well on November 25 (1-0 win) and on November 26 (2-3 loss) with only three goals allowed on 49 shots. But in their final meeting in 2011-12, the Devils put three past him out of 20 shots on April 3 in a 3-1 win. Last night, he got them all. Next time, who knows?

The main point is that one never truly knows what you're going to get from an unfamiliar goalie. Even established and experienced goalies can have slumps of erratic play or streaks of excellence. So someone who doesn't start regularly is even more of a wildcard. Sure, we can look at the what goalie has or has not done in the past to see whether we should be worried. But on any given night, a goalie can get hot. Even so, in the larger picture of a whole season, most of the non-regular starters - the backups, if you will - are not regularly starting for a reason. It shouldn't be a surprise that they would have a worse save percentage when they start against New Jersey than the regulars.

So regardless of Montoya's shut out last night, I don't think non-#1 goalies will give the 2013-14 Devils much trouble over the whole season like the 2009-10 team did. The last three seasons suggest otherwise in spite of the Devils putting up so low shooting percentages. You don't even have to go far to find a counter example within this season. Jason LaBarbera, the Oilers' #2 goalie for now, certainly didn't play like that last Monday. I understand where that line of thinking comes from, but the numbers do not fully support it.

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior users will need to choose a permanent username, along with a new password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

I already have a Vox Media account!

Verify Vox Media account

Please login to your Vox Media account. This account will be linked to your previously existing Eater account.

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior MT authors will need to choose a new username and password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join In Lou We Trust

You must be a member of In Lou We Trust to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at In Lou We Trust. You should read them.

Join In Lou We Trust

You must be a member of In Lou We Trust to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at In Lou We Trust. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.